top of page

Articles and Polemics
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم والحمد لله الأول قبل الإنشاء والآخر بعد فناء الأشياء
Search


Did Fatima (AS) forgive Abu Bakr before her death?
One of the most common defenses that our opponents use with regards to the dispute between Fatima (AS) and Abu Bakr is that before Fatima’s death, she and Abu Bakr met and amicably ended their dispute, and she was pleased with him before she died.
This narrative is one which we have examined and have found to be quite absurd. We shall present a comprehensive refutation for it in the hopes that our Shia brothers and sisters benefit and know how to respond in case they come ac

Anonymous
May 1421 min read
339
0


The Fadak Series: Introduction
In the name of Allah, the Almighty, the Most Merciful and Compassionate, who has perfected all of His creation. Fadak was a significant...

Anonymous
Jan 262 min read
402
0


The Fadak Series Part XIII: Fadak was "returned" to Banu Hashim?
When Fadak was usurped from Banu Hashim initally by Abu Bakr, it went through many transfers through out history to many different clans...

Anonymous
Jan 148 min read
183
0


The Fadak Series XII: Why didn't Ali reclaim Fadak?
Instead of directly addressing the issues related to Abu Bakr's arguments our opponents deflect by focusing on trivial arguments that...

Anonymous
Jan 1012 min read
272
0


The Fadak Series Part XI: Ali believes Abu Bakr is a liar, sinful, treacherous and dishonest!
After Abu Bakr's death, Ali and al-Abbas go to Umar b. al-Khattab requesting for Fadak once more. This request creates major problems for...

Anonymous
Jan 99 min read
180
0


The Fadak Series Part X: Shaykh al-Mufid's grammatical argument to Abu Bakr's Hadith for inheritance
Al-Shaykh al-Mufid was famously known as the head of the Imamiyah and one of the strongest opponents of Ahlus Sunnah, being praised by...

Anonymous
Jan 77 min read
263
0


The Fadak Series Part IX: The Significance of Fatima's Anger
In the previous part, we have discussed Fatima's anger and boycott against Abu Bakr for the crimes he had committed against her. She dema...

Anonymous
Jan 514 min read
213
0


The Fadak Series VIII: Fatima's anger and boycott of Abu Bakr
When Fatima (as) had exhausted all her efforts to reclaim Fadak and found no success, she let go of her pursuit. She ceased to argue, for...

Anonymous
Jan 215 min read
264
0


The Fadak Series Part VII: Abu Bakr's Confession...
When Fatima (as) had her testimonies rejected and her right to inheritance denied, she stood firm in her stance against Abu Bakr...

Anonymous
Jan 116 min read
188
0


The Fadak Series Part VI: Does Fatima inherit Fadak in Shi'i sources?
A popular misconception that is spread around about the Shi'a is that within their own sources it is proven that Fatima (as) does...

Anonymous
Dec 30, 202415 min read
219
0


The Fadak Series Part V: Did the Prophet (saw) leave inheritance?
We have discussed previously that the hadith of Abu Bakr that was brought as a response to Fatima (as) directly contradicts the Qur'an...

Anonymous
Dec 28, 202410 min read
203
0


The Fadak Series Part IV: Prophetic Inheritance in the Qur'an
When Fatima (as)'s access to Fadak was cut away, and presented with the hadith of Abu Bakr that was mentioned in the previous part...

Anonymous
Dec 27, 202422 min read
200
2


The Fadak Series Part II: Those that testified for Fatima (as)
After the death of the Prophet (saw), Fatima (as) found herself in a situation where she no longer had possession of Fadak...

Anonymous
Dec 26, 202438 min read
398
1


The Fadak Series Part III: Abu Bakr's mysterious Hadith
Upon the death of the Prophet, Abu Bakr argued that the right of Fatima (as) to Fadak suddenly disappears and that only he knew of this...

Anonymous
Dec 24, 202417 min read
477
1


The Fadak Series Part I: The value of Fadak
The significance of Fadak enabled the Ahl al-Bayt (as) to generate revenue and utilize it for trading, but when this land was confiscated...

Anonymous
Dec 23, 20247 min read
476
0
bottom of page